Hey regular readers, I'm sorry it's been a while. I got so many dang hits from Cockeyed I didn't want to blog and disappoint those folks. Like, they'd click the link over here and wonder what the hell all this random bitching about traffic and home improvement and the life of a high school teacher was. Anyway, I do have stuff to say on all those topics and more (notably in the life of a high school teacher, some notes on my new classroom, including demolition and fleas), but first, I just can't NOT talk about last night.
First of all, let me just say that a month ago, I lost my wallet, inside which were my ticket stubs from a Patti Smith concert, a Violent Femmes concert, and a Nine Inch Nails concert. I no longer have those, and I’ll never be able to get them back, but at least I have my memories. The ticket stub I do have now, though, is for this year’s American Idol tour. That’s right. I went to the American Idol tour. I’m going to go ahead and refer to it as “AI” from now on, because it’s easier, and it seems fitting in the sense that those initials tend to remind one of artificial intelligence. And artificial it was.
Why did I go? Well, a year ago, a friend of my mom’s was getting rid of a vintage O’Keefe and Merrit stove, and gave it to me for free even though they can be sold for thousands of dollars. And that very woman bought something like 8 tickets to this concert, assuming that everyone she knew would want to attend. She had miscalculated, and now needed people to go with her and use the tickets. In a desperate bid, she asked my mom, and my mom asked me. We both thought it would be gracious to accept, and since we both like this friend and my mom’s other friend B, who was also attending, we decided to go. Sigh.
Well, I have seen two worse concerts than this one. The first was at the Distillery years ago. A Johnny Cash cover band called “Folsom Prison Blues” slaughtered the man in black’s songs for about 45 minutes, and I was ready to cry. Then a few weeks ago, I saw a GREAT show with Daycare, the Snobs, and the Skirts. The show leaned toward the rock/pop-punk side of things. Great bands, all. A surprise addition to the bill, however, called the Slick Boys, was rather a surprise -- they were synchronized-dancing R&B lip-synching drag kings. Now, I have nothing against drag kings, lip synching, or synchronized dancing per se, and although R&B is not my favorite genre, I don’t hate it, but the effect of all these things together, coupled with the facts that they are not very good and were stuck in the middle of an unsuitable show for them, and the result was pretty rotten.
But enough stalling. On to AI. Oh, do I have to? I hardly care to re-live the evening. I certainly have no intention of giving you a play-by-play, but rather some general impressions and notes. First of all, it was so incredibly scripted, choreographed, and over-produced as to have made me a little nauseated. Each one of the “Idols” had clearly been taught the same wave, for example; they reached one arm at a time straight out toward the crowd, then wiggled only their fingers from the knuckles down. No elbow, no wrist. It looked strange on the girls, but on the men, it was utterly emasculating. Every single performer went to one side of the stage, waved multiple times, then walked to the other side and waved there.
I also hated the “shout-outs” to our town. Perhaps the local girl really was happy to be here, but everyone else had certainly been coached backstage to say “I’m so excited to be here in SacTOWN.” The worst, really possibly EVER, was when Chris sang “Wanted: Dead or Alive,” and changed the lyric “I ride all night just to get back home” to “I ride all night just to get to Sacramento.” I mean, how insulting, really.
Other creepy things included the extreme close-up of Ace’s chest as the first strains of George Michael’s “Father Figure” began to play -- he was pushing his chest out towards the camera in an ooky impression of a heartbeat. And when he sang the lyric “To be bold and naked at your side,” he took his jacket off at the “naked.”
I have to say that Elvis, Freddie Mercury, Patsy Cline, and Judy Garland are all rolling in their graves. When the following artists die, I assume they, too, will commence to rolling: Bob Seger, Melissa Etheridge, K.T. Tunstall, Aretha Franklin, Gladys Knight, Beyonce Knowles, Axl Rose, Jon Bon Jovi, Robert Plant, Stevie Wonder, and even Olivia Newton-John and John Travolta. Hell, Uncle Kracker is probably on that list. I was seriously thinking as one of the guys sang -- “well, he’s no Uncle Kracker.” Is there any worse insult than “You’re no Uncle Kracker?” Really.
I just hate it when they cover songs I love, and I actually heard the first two notes of “Whole Lotta Love” and turned to Mom screaming “Not Led Zeppelin!!” Incidentally, my horrified screaming could not be heard (twice) over the enthusiastic screaming of the crowd.
Other surreal moments occurred when I heard songs like “Patience” and “Wanted: Dead or Alive.” Did anyone think, twenty years ago, that these songs would bring entire stadiums to their feet in twenty years’ time? Did anyone know that kids who had not been born when the songs came out, kids who, in all probability, have never even HEARD the original versions, would sing their lungs out when the microphone was pointed towards them during the chorus? So odd, really. Also, I could practically smell the pierogis in the Kit Carson middle school cafeteria, where we held our afternoon dances. I remember swaying in tiny circles, knees locked, with Tony Winter’s arms around me. “I been walkin’ the streets at night... just tryin’ to get it right...”
As the concert started rolling towards its conclusion, the winner, Taylor, came on stage and began doing his crazy dance. And I thought to myself, of all the thousands of people that auditioned for this show from all over the country, this bowlegged, funky dancing, bushy-eyebrowed Elvis-butchering motherfucker is the best they could do? He’s our American Idol? Really? This is it? Because I know that there are better singers, better performers, actual songwriters, and real artists playing in shitty bars in tiny towns all over the country every single weekend.
One of the saddest moments, I think, was watching one of these girls sing Aretha Franklin’s “Think.” Having seen Aretha perform this song in “The Blues Brothers,” I couldn’t help but see Aretha superimposed over whichever sad, pale imitation was performing there in front of me. It was like a palimpset of the real song, with the soulless, thin version there underneath. What a stark contrast. And I realized that the whole concert was like that -- a history of American (and, okay, British) music with all the passion, love, and soul surgically excised. It was almost like a horror movie, where you find yourself in a parallel universe with all the good parts of life removed. Have you read “A Wrinkle in Time”? There’s a part where Meg and her brothers are eating a fabulous spread of a meal. Her brother is brainwashed into thinking that it is all, indeed, gourmet food, whereas Meg tastes only sand. I was tasting sand, but everyone else around seeed to taste Turkish delight.
There is an upside, though. And that is this: AI is not actually representative of modern music or the pool of talent in this country at all. It couldn’t be, because they don’t foster art or creativity. They seem to think they are weeding out bad singers in favor of good singers, but what they will never have is great singers, because a great singer is something else entirely. Van Morrison? Not a good singer, but nevertheless a great singer. Hell, he’d never have made it to round one. He’s funny-looking and short and stalks across the stage in an odd manner, and his voice is gruff and strange. Janis Joplin? Breathy. Bob Seger? Awful. James Taylor? No stage presence. Joe Cocker? Don’t quit your day job. Chrissie Hynde? Not an accessible look. David Byrne? Pitchy. So you know what? Let’s let American Idol keep being what it is, and let music keep being what it is, and understand that they are two different universes. And next year if I get asked to go to Season 5’s concert? I’m afraid I’m busy that day.