Subsequent to the news of this breaking, I learned that there are a TON of men online who gather in virtual communities to commiserate about similar things.
Now, I already knew about Men's Rights Activists. If you haven't heard of them, their party line goes something like this: women get the better hand dealt to them in society, because child custody cases are often found in their favor, because they don't have to register for the draft, and because fewer of them have died in wars over the last couple centuries. Also, men are hurt by women's suspicion of them: a woman's fear that a man following her might rape or kill her is less important than the man-following-her's being unfairly judged.
Sometimes one of these MRA guys will show up on a feminist blog I follow, and someone will respond empathetically but reasonably: "Hey, we care about the custody issue, too! Feminism is about equality." And then generally one of these guys will shoot back with "Well, it won't be equal until as many women die in wars as men have, so let's start lining up all the women and shipping them to combat zones."
And then most everybody goes like this.
But this community was new to me. These guys call themselves "wizards" (apparently there's an in-joke that if you get to 30 as a virgin, you become a wizard) or "incels" (short for "involuntary celibate").
The feminist blog was sort of... visited by a bunch of these guys after reporting on the Rodgers killings. And their philosophy seems to go like this: Women label them as "creeps" simply for being shy. Once a woman decides you're a creep, all women are alerted to this, and they create a vast conspiracy wherein no woman will sleep with you. Women are denying them the sex they are owed. Further, rape is really not that bad, because women sometimes have intercourse voluntarily, and they can recover from it. Whereas these men suffer in their loneliness daily, and it is therefore much worse. A few of them take that to its logical extreme: it would make sense to rape women.
Obviously, that's a pretty mentally ill standpoint. But that's where these guys live: they are owed sex by virtue of being alive, and the fact that it's not happening is an active denial on the part of those nefarious women.
Here's the thing they can't see -- if they're being called creeps, it's probably because they're CREEPY.
I'm going to say some things about my husband for a second that may sound negative. He's a D&D playing, Dr. Who-watching, introverted G.I. Joe collector with no car who would not/did not make the first move. By their logic, I should never have married him. He should be one of them! He's (in their minds) just like them!
But I never thought for a second that he was creepy. Without knowing these guys personally, here's what I'd guess they lack that he has: he's well-groomed (clean, non-smelly, face and head hair are attended to, clothing is clean and cared-for). He's charming, and can make conversation with basically anyone (though he doesn't love to). He's funny. He's savvy about politics and world affairs. He's well-read. He's smart. He is fit. He's polite (and has good table manners, etc.). He appears at ease with women (me included/especially).
I started thinking about many of the other men in my life -- various degrees of nerds, cyclists, metal-heads, etc. And pretty much all of them ended up with attractive, talented, funny, normal women. Because they're NOT creeps. And they don't believe they are owed anything. They were looking for connections with women based on common interests, and they treat those women respectfully.
I watched one of the Elliot Rodgers videos. In it, he seems angry that a woman is with another man. Where is *his* woman, he wonders? That other guy isn't even very good-looking! But the whole time, he's speaking with an affect that would be chilling even if you weren't aware that this is the guy who killed seven people.
I don't think these guys could actually listen to reason -- they're so immersed in their own worldview that it's too late to try to convince them otherwise -- but if I could, I'd make a few suggestions. First, if someone calls you a fedora-wearing neckbeard, ditch the statement hat and shave. It's not a super-attractive grooming choice that others are spitefully shaming you for, it genuinely looks weird and unkempt. Second, make sure your clothes fit, are clean, and are, if not "in style," at least somewhat timeless. Third, shower daily, brush your teeth, and get your hair cut every six weeks or so. Fourth, get out of the house. If you spend hours a day in your internet community, that is valuable being-in-the-world time you're missing out on. Go play tennis. Or go to a whiskey tasting. Or adopt a dog and take it to the dog park. Take a class in something. Not only will all these things probably improve your life by themselves, but sometimes WOMEN go out in public too, and you might meet one you have something in common with. You don't have to have a nice car, but it does have to be free of fast-food bags and smell clean. You don't have to have a great job, but you probably should have one. Or be in school.
The world owes you nothing. But you can bend the pathways of your life to make it more easy for things to come to you. And you can be happy, to an extent, with what you have instead of seething with anger (which generally gets you nowhere). It's like "The Secret" but with less woo-woo. If you have a positive attitude and work towards some goals, people will tend to want to be around you more, women included. If you're angry and hateful and resentful, no, a woman is not very likely to fall into your lap.